Minggu ni, malas nak komen, tp vote aku pegi utk Cicik lagi... And abg farihin mmg baguih, he stressed the point that pendakwah in general has to be in the public.. ni sama sekali membuang ke dalam parit semua penasyid2 yg pandai nyanyi aje, walhal qudwah bil-hal nya entah ke mana...
Yg pelik, Farhan... camne leh jatuh bottom 3???? Vocals power camtu... Ye la, walopun point abg farihin tu betol, kene lembut kan utk sesuai lagu, but at least diorg tried somethin new (not new actually, dah lama penasyid patut adopt this style of singing), compared to the week before, aku suka, bunyi triads nye yg jelas... So camne leh bottom 3 nih? Adakah khalayak Malaysia mmg x reti tgk bakat? Atau adakah undi panel juri tidak memberi impak? Atau adakah sistem undian 50%-50% tidak dpt memberi result sewajarnya... Masing2 boleh jawab utk diri sendiri... Aku malas nak analisa... (diorg ni [minggu ni lah] macam paragon child [gangstarz], pengetahuan juri x setaraf diorg utk komen, sori ye bang ajai, aku x setuju komen abg pasal bohemian rhapsody tu, entah abg penah dgr ke x, bohemian rhapsody tu one of the finest arrangements in a cappella tau.. dan diorg bawak bertiga, walhal vocal lines asal adalah 4 or 5 lines, itu sudah cukup buktikan diorang tau pilih which vocal lines are important than others)
Yg x adil juga, pembuangan grup Sofia (betoi ke eja nih)... Berbanding Aiman, who sings solo, sebuah kumpulan perlu diberi peluang lebih lama, sbb? Well jawab la sendiri.. Dlm kumpulan, banyak isu nak disetelkan,... nyanyi berkumpulan bukannyo sonang... compared to singing solo, u have nothing to worry abut except yourself (well, vocally, presentation-wise and so on - in Sofia's case, multiply that by 4)...
Sama ngan minggu lepas Azhan Atan & Cicik aje yg feel...
Farhan meningkat dr minggu lepas...
Voice of men.. well harmoni dah makin ok...Cuma aku x suka korg ni, nape korg suka bawak macam artis asal.. cuba la lainkan arangement, or tambah countertenor ke or apa2lah... man, try to improvise wherever suits la...
Muslim Voice, komen aku sama mcm minggu lepas.. watpe buat beat box... bass lagi penting, sbb bass mampu menonjolkan chords.. tambah penting lagi, bila triads korg mcm x nampak aje... that is why, i have to say every now and then,... the bass, the bass and the bass... beat box akan sedap kalu bass ade... Show korg minggu ni buat aku hampa.. u r the only participant yg berani wat a cappella, but.. donno what to say... and pak solo, what happened to u??? Grup ni menurun compared minggu lepas...
In heart, berani.. grup yg berani.. itu je.. tapi berani je x cukup ma... u should analyse your performance minggu ni and minggu lepas...
Eda peserta yg menampakkan beliau paham apa itu aurat (well, physically lah, as i see it)... Vocals pun ok.. and like bung farihin said, vocals je dah cukup... jgn dakwah jadi goda sudah lah (this goes to all k)
Yg lain aku tak komen, sbb below standard & below average.. not worth commenting, unless improvement is shown in the weeks to come...
Pasal yg patut dibuang, x lain x bukan... korg pikir la sendiri.. sama mcm minggu lepas
nasyeed.com
Diskusi @ Nasyeed . COM
